The untamed earl by Valerie Bowman

The Untamed Earl (Playful Brides, #5)The Untamed Earl by Valerie Bowman
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Short synopsis: Alex who is in love with Owen pretends to help him woo her shrewish sister in order to win him for herself.

I loved the first half which was funny, witty and totally enjoyable. The second half turned into a generic romance with the usual misunderstandings and overreactions. It felt like I had switched books which I found disappointing. If I could I would give 4 stars / 2 stars, so settled for 3 in the end.

The first half was mostly interaction between Alex and Owen during their “lessons” – him teaching her how to become an accomplished debutante, her teaching him about her sister’s supposed likes and dislikes – and between Alex or Owen and Lavinia. I very much enjoyed this part.

All of a sudden the atmosphere changed. Alex and a few friends plotted to get Owen to acknowledge his feelings for her and unfortunately the usual romance storyline began. When Owen – as a result of the plot – acts rather foolishly at one point Alex got mad and turned away from him. This goes back and forth a bit until eventually they make up. After that their love seems established but Lavinia, a right bitch, throws a spanner in the works, Alex believes the lie and again wants nothing to do with Owen. How about talking to him properly like they did in the beginning instead of jumping to idiotic conclusions?

All these situations in the second half of the book were so unnatural and out of character that I got seriously annoyed and even started skimming pages. There is a sex scene that came unexpected and that was unnecessary, therefore not very enjoyable. Believe me, for me to complain about a love scene it really has to be against the rhythm.

I enjoyed the writing and the initial story idea but the decline into the typical romance behaviour later on eventually ruined the book for me. Pity!

On a sidenote: According to the author this is a re-telling of The Taming of the Shrew, only the shrew being a rogue. I cannot see that at all. Why Owen would be considered a “shrew” is beyond me. The shrew is Lavinia – and she is in desperate need of taming indeed.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

View all my reviews

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *.


Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

CommentLuv badge